Updated: 20 March 2026

Originally Published: 31 March 2025

​

Across the UK, thousands of drivers are reviewing older vehicle finance agreements after learning more about the car finance scandal and how certain deals were structured. For many people, the discovery raises an important question.

Could I be entitled to a car finance refund?

Concerns about car finance mis-selling have grown steadily over the past few years, particularly in relation to Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) and Hire Purchase (HP) agreements. Many drivers did not realise that commission arrangements between lenders and dealerships could influence the interest rate they were offered.

In some cases, borrowers paid more than necessary without understanding why.

As awareness has increased, more consumers are checking their agreements, exploring car finance claims, and asking whether they may qualify for car finance compensation.

This guide explains everything drivers should know about car finance refunds in 2026, including:

• what the car finance scandal involves
• how mis-sold car finance situations arise
• why PCP agreements are frequently examined
• who may qualify for a refund
• how to check eligibility
• how to claim car finance refunds
• what happens during the claims process

Reviewing your agreement could help you know whether a car finance claim is worth exploring, particularly if you financed a vehicle between 2007 and 2024.

Key Takeaways

Before diving into the detail, here are the most important points about car finance refunds.

• The car finance scandal centres on commission structures that could influence interest rates.
• Many drivers were unaware that dealerships could adjust the interest rate offered.
• Agreements signed between 2007 and 2024 are often being reviewed.
• PCP agreements account for a large share of current car finance claims.
• Some drivers can explore claims even if their finance agreement has already ended.
• A car finance refund check can help determine whether your agreement may warrant further investigation.

Understanding the Car Finance Scandal

The rise in car finance claims throughout the UK has been connected to worries about the way vehicle finance agreements have been written up over the past two decades. One key problem is discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs). In these cases, lenders allowed the broker or dealership to have a say over the rate of interest given to the customer. The lender might set a base interest rate, but then the dealer could raise that rate up to a limit.

The key point is this.

The higher the interest rate charged to the borrower, the higher the commission the broker could receive.

Many customers were not clearly told that this flexibility existed. Instead, they often believed the interest rate was fixed or determined purely by their credit score.

This created a potential conflict of interest. A broker could earn more by offering a higher interest rate rather than the lowest rate available.

Because of these concerns, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) banned discretionary commission arrangements in January 2021 [1].

However, millions of agreements had already been signed before that change.

These historic agreements are now being examined as part of the wider car finance scandal UK, which has prompted many drivers to review older finance deals.

How Interest Rate Flexibility Increased Borrowing Costs

To understand why the issue is important, it helps to look at how commission structures affected borrowing costs.

When a lender approved a finance application, they often set a base interest rate for the customer. Under discretionary commission arrangements, the dealer could then increase that rate within a permitted range.

For example:

• the lender might approve finance at 5% APR
• the dealership might offer the customer 7% APR
• the difference could generate additional commission

From the customer's perspective, the interest rate simply appeared as part of the finance agreement.

Unless the commission structure was made crystal clear to them, many borrowers would have no reason to wonder whether the rate might have been lower.

A small difference in interest rate can make a big difference to the cost of borrowing. Over a few years, the extra payments can amount to hundreds, even thousands, of pounds.

This is why interest rate discretion is now central to many discussions about mis-sold car finance.

Why Hidden Commission Structures Created Problems

Commission itself is not unusual in financial products. Many industries use commission to reward brokers or intermediaries.

The concern arises when the commission structure is not explained clearly and may influence pricing.

In some vehicle finance agreements, borrowers were not aware that:

• the dealership could adjust the interest rate
• the dealer’s commission might increase if the rate increased
• alternative rates may have been available

Without this information, customers could not easily judge whether the deal they were offered represented fair value.

When this lack of transparency affects the cost of borrowing, it may raise questions about car finance mis-selling.

What Is Mis-Sold Car Finance?

The phrase mis-sold car finance is where a borrower entered into a finance agreement without receiving clear or complete information about the product.

It does not automatically mean the agreement was illegal.

Instead, it means the consumer may not have been given the information needed to make a fully informed decision.

Examples of potential car finance mis-selling include:

• commission arrangements not clearly disclosed
• interest rates influenced by broker incentives
• incomplete explanation of the total amount payable
• pressure to sign finance agreements quickly
• inadequate comparison with other finance options

In many cases, customers focused mainly on the monthly payment rather than the full structure of the finance agreement.

These issues now form the basis of many investigations on PCP claims and car finance claims.

Why PCP Agreements Are Frequently Linked to Claims

Personal Contract Purchase agreements are one of the most common ways to finance vehicles in the UK [2].

They became popular because they typically offer:

• lower monthly payments
• flexibility at the end of the agreement
• the ability to change vehicles regularly

At the end of a PCP agreement, drivers usually have three options.

1. return the car
2. pay the final balloon payment and keep the vehicle
3. trade the car for another vehicle

While PCP agreements work well for many drivers, they were also frequently associated with discretionary commission arrangements.

Because PCP deals often involve a large balloon payment and longer terms, even small increases in interest rates can have a noticeable impact on the overall cost of the agreement.

For that reason, PCP claims represent a significant share of current car finance claims.

If you would like to understand how compensation is sometimes calculated, you can read more here.

Who Might Be Eligible for a Car Finance Refund

Eligibility for car finance compensation depends on the specific details of the agreement.

However, many drivers reviewing their agreements today signed finance deals between 2007 and 2024, when discretionary commission arrangements were widely used.

You may want to explore a car finance refund check if:

• the vehicle was financed through PCP or hire purchase
• the agreement was arranged through a dealership or broker
• the interest rate was not clearly explained
• commission structures were not disclosed
• the total cost of the finance was unclear

It is also important to know that the agreement does not need to still be active.

Many drivers assume they cannot pursue car finance refunds once the finance has been paid off.

In reality, settled agreements may still be reviewed. You can read more about this here.

What Evidence Is Usually Needed for a Claim

When exploring car finance claims, documentation often clarify how the agreement was structured:

• the original finance agreement
• payment statements
• emails or letters from the lender
• pre-contract information sheets

These documents help establish:

• the interest rate offered
• the lender involved
• the dealership that arranged the finance
• the total amount payable

If you no longer have these documents, lenders may still hold copies because financial institutions often retain records for several years.

Organising Documents for a Stronger Claim

Organise your documents clearly if you decide to explore a car finance claim:

• keep digital copies of agreements and statements
• highlight key details such as interest rates or fees
• note the dates the agreement started and ended

With clear documentation, the complaint process will run more smoothly, making it easier to explain your concerns to the lender.

How to Check Whether Your Agreement May Qualify

If you are unsure whether your agreement may involve car finance mis-selling, the first step is usually to review the basic details of the finance deal.

Key information includes:

• the lender who provided the finance
• the start date of the agreement
• the type of finance used
• the dealership involved

Many drivers begin with a car finance refund check to determine whether their agreement may warrant further review.

Some people also use tools designed to estimate eligibility, such as a car finance claim calculator or a mis-sold car finance calculator. These tools can help drivers understand whether their agreement may fall within the scope of current investigations.

It is important to remember that these checks are only an initial step. They help clarify whether a claim may be worth exploring.

They do not submit a formal complaint.

How to Claim a Car Finance Refund

If you believe your agreement may involve car finance mis-selling, the process typically involves several stages.

Step 1. Review your finance agreement

Start by checking the key terms of the agreement, including:

• the interest rate
• the total amount payable
• the lender
• the dealership involved

If you do not have the paperwork, lenders may still hold copies.

Step 2. Check your eligibility

For many drivers, the first step is to carry out a car finance refund check to see if their agreement could potentially be caught by the ongoing investigations.

The refund check is then used to see if proceeding with a car finance claim is right for you.

Step 3. Submit a complaint to the lender

If there are signs that the agreement may have been mis-sold, a formal complaint can be submitted to the lender explaining the concerns.

The lender must investigate the complaint and respond.

Step 4. Escalate the case if necessary

If the complaint is rejected or unresolved, the case may be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service for independent review.

You can read a full explanation of the process here.

How Long Do Car Finance Claims Take?

The timeline for PCP claims and other car finance claims can vary.

Factors affecting timelines include:

• the complexity of the agreement
• the lender involved
• regulatory developments affecting the industry

Some cases may be resolved relatively quickly, while others take longer if additional investigation is required.

You can read a detailed breakdown of typical timelines here.

Why Many Drivers Are Checking Their Agreements Now

The increase in car finance claims and PCP claims shows that drivers are waking up to the way vehicle finance agreements were sold.

Drivers may have believed for years that their finance agreement was just a loan product.

It is only in recent years that the impact of commission structures has been openly discussed.

As a result, more drivers are asking questions such as:

• Was the interest rate explained clearly?
• Was commission disclosed?
• Did the broker have flexibility over the rate?
• Did I pay more than necessary?

Exploring these questions does not automatically mean you will receive a car finance refund.

However, reviewing the agreement can help clarify whether the finance deal was structured transparently.

Why Reviewing Your Agreement Matters

For many families, car finance is the biggest single financial transaction they will ever undertake. Small changes in the interest rate can make a big difference to the total cost of the loan. A small adjustment to the interest rate can mean hundreds or thousands of pounds in extra payments over the term of the loan. Take a look at your agreement with a car finance refund check and find out whether your car finance agreement was concluded in a fair and transparent manner.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a car finance refund?

A car finance refund is compensation that may be paid if a finance agreement was mis-sold or arranged unfairly. It typically relates to excess interest or costs linked to how the agreement was structured.

Can I claim if my finance agreement has ended?

Yes. In many cases, car finance claims can still be explored even if the agreement has been fully repaid.

Are PCP agreements the only ones affected?

No. While many PCP claims are being reviewed, other finance agreements such as hire purchase may also be examined if concerns about car finance mis-selling arise.

How do I know if my agreement qualifies?

Many drivers begin with a car finance refund check to review the key details of the agreement. Some also use a car finance claim calculator to estimate whether their agreement may warrant further investigation.

Does checking my eligibility mean I am making a claim?

No. Checking eligibility is simply an information step. It helps determine whether a car finance claim may be relevant to your situation.

Final Thoughts

The increase in car finance claims across the UK reflects a growing reassessment of how vehicle finance agreements were structured over the past two decades.

But the conversation doesn’t always start or end with the potential to reclaim funds. A number of motorists are also considering whether the car finance agreement they signed up to was clear in its terms and fairly priced.

If you’ve bought a car on finance between 2007 and 2024, it might be worth taking a look at your car finance agreement to see if the concerns over mis-sold car finance may apply to you.

Use our car finance refund checker to establish your position, and see if it could be worthwhile to investigate making a claim.

_________

References:

1. the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) banned discretionary commission arrangements in January 2021 - https://www.fca.org.uk/news/press-releases/fca-ban-motor-finance-discretionary-commission-models
2. Personal Contract Purchase agreements are one of the most common ways to finance vehicles in the UK - https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp25-27-technical-annex-2.pdf